The Blue Jays have announced that Trey Yesavage will pitch Game #2 of the series against the New York Yankees. So tomorrow, he'll face none other than Max Fried in Toronto.
Shane Bieber, meanwhile, will pitch game #3 against Carlos Rodon.
Game 2: Max Fried vs. Trey Yesavage
Game 3: Carlos Rodón vs. Shane Bieber– Bryan Hoch
(@BryanHoch) October 4, 2025
If someone had told you, when the Blue Jays had six starters a few weeks ago, that Trey Yesavage (who wasn't one of the six) would be pitching Game 2 of the playoffs, would you have believed them?
The way he's pitched this season, the Blue Jays are surely hoping he'll have a Cam Schlittler-like impact in the playoffs. But not going with Bieber is still a risk.
If the club loses today's game, it's going to be complicated to manage for the rest of the season, isn't it?
It's worth noting that when Bieber learned he was entitled to game #2, he was really happy. John Schneider said he couldn't repeat his protégé's words publicly, but the latter feels ready.
Trey Yesavage: “I'm built for this”
– Ben Nicholson-Smith (@bnicholsonsmith) October 4, 2025
Having said that, it's worth mentioning that having Yesavage play at home before a day off is undoubtedly one of the factors that prompted the Blue Jays to make this decision.
No pressure, kid.
Speaking of pitchers, Max Scherzer was not added to the lineup because of the opponent. Had it been the Red Sox, John Schneider might have selected him. Remember, it takes lefties against the Bombardiers' left-handed hitters…
But even so, MadMax will be in the dugout to cheer on his teammates.
Blue Jays manager John Schneider says Max Scherzer likely would have been on Blue Jays ALDS roster if the club was playing the Red Sox; didn't like matchup vs Yankees.
Schneider also says Chris Bassitt wasn't stretched out far enough following his back injury to factor in.
– Arden Zwelling (@ArdenZwelling) October 4, 2025

- If there's a #4 game, Louis Varland and Eric Lauer should see some action.
If there's a G4 could be something like Louis Varland and Eric Lauer per John Schneider
– Ben Nicholson-Smith (@bnicholsonsmith) October 4, 2025
- Yankees go 26 position players.
Yankees go 14 position players, 12 pitchers with their ALDS roster for series with Blue Jays: pic.twitter.com/soR713IgZK
– Shi Davidi (@ShiDavidi) October 4, 2025
- Max Fried respects the Blue Jays.
Max Fried on the Blue Jays
“A really good lineup. They're gonna battle. They're not going to give up many easy outs, put the ball in play, and make you earn it.”
– Brandon Wile (@Brandon_N_Wile) October 4, 2025
- Today's starting line-ups.
YOUR GAME ONE LINEUP
![]()
Bring the noise. #WANTITALL pic.twitter.com/EdLQU4ne98
– Toronto Blue Jays (@BlueJays) October 4, 2025
Game 1 in Toronto. #RepBX pic.twitter.com/2zsIPD6atl
– New York Yankees (@Yankees) October 4, 2025
This content was created with the help of AI.
(@BryanHoch)
YOUR GAME ONE LINEUP