The Eagles are being praised for their perfect summer, while the Bills are receiving a concerning grade

The busiest time of the year in the NFL is now over.

With free agency over, the 2026 draft now complete, and the final trades concluded after June 1, all 32 franchises have virtually finished building their rosters ahead of the start of training camp.

This makes it the perfect time to take stock of the offseason by assigning a grade to each team. However, this evaluation isn't based solely on the players signed or lost. The primary goal is to analyze the quality of the decisions made by team management—whether they involve signings, trades, roster cuts, coaching staff hires, or the overall strategy for building the roster.

A franchise can certainly field a more competitive roster without necessarily having had an excellent offseason. While some teams have indeed bolstered their talent, they've done so at the cost of risky contracts or questionable choices that could weigh on their future. Conversely, other organizations have chosen to prepare for the future by prioritizing financial stability and the development of young players.

It is also important to note that this analysis focuses exclusively on decisions made during the 2026 offseason. Some clubs currently have a significant number of draft picks or a comfortable salary cap space thanks to decisions made several months earlier. These factors are therefore not directly taken into account in this evaluation.

A Comprehensive Analysis of the Franchises' Strategic Choices

Several criteria were used to determine these ratings: the soundness of the contracts signed, the value obtained in trades, payroll management, the hiring of coaches and executives, and the consistency of the short- and long-term sports strategy.

The goal is not to single out the teams that simply signed the biggest names, but rather those that made the smartest decisions to build a sustainably competitive roster. Some teams are aiming directly for the Super Bowl, while others are pursuing a more gradual rebuild.

Now let's take a closer look at the 32 franchises and analyze their moves during the 2026 NFL offseason to determine which ones truly had a successful summer and which ones will soon have to justify their decisions on the field.