Injured defenseman: The Habs pulled out of two deals involving right-handed defensemen at the trade deadline
Right-handed defensemen are a rare commodity in the National Hockey League.
Generally speaking, it's easier to find a left-handed defenseman, which makes right-handed defensemen highly valuable on the trade market.
It is often a priority for many teams during the offseason and at the trade deadline to acquire a right-handed defenseman capable of playing on a top-4 pairing.
In fact, at the recent trade deadline on March 6, the Canadiens were among the teams potentially looking for a right-handed defenseman.
There were several rumors to that effect, and since then, we've been learning more and more about the deals in which the Habs were involved.
Pierre LeBrun, who was a guest on the Sick Podcast, confirmed earlier this week that Kenyt Hughes pulled out of two right-handed defenseman deals—those involving Rasmus Ristolainen and Connor Murphy.
Pierre LeBrun: Re Canadiens: They tried to acquire Connor Murphy; they tried to acquire Rasmus Ristolainen; sometimes the best trades you make are the ones you didn't make; given some of the prices…there's just as good a chance the Canadiens would've regretted [it] – Sick Podcast/Tony Marinaro (4/1)
— NHL Rumour Report (@NHLRumourReport) April 3, 2026
LeBrun explained that the Canadiens ultimately decided against overpaying for either defenseman, considering it a risky move that could have been just as beneficial as it could have been regrettable.
I agree that the trades you don't make can sometimes be the best ones, but with Alexandre Carrier's recent injury, I'm sure Kent Hughes has to reconsider those two deals at least a little.
Since Carrier is right-handed, his injury means the Habs now have five left-handed defensemen (Hutson, Guhle, Matheson, Struble, and Xhekaj) on the blue line, and only one right-handed defenseman in Noah Dobson.
This isn't the end of the world, of course, but it can sometimes hinder the performance of left-handed defensemen who are forced to play on the right side.
If Kent Hughes had decided to overpay for Murphy or Ristolainen, the Habs' defense wouldn't have been so disrupted and altered by Carrier's injury.
Ultimately, Martin St-Louis finds himself in a bit of a bind, as he has to rely on Arber Xhekaj and Jayden Struble at the same time every night, which is clearly not ideal for the head coach, especially in the final stretch leading up to the playoffs.
In short, I'm not saying that Kent Hughes made a mistake by backing out of those two deals at the trade deadline, but I'm sure he must be thinking he'd be in a better position right now.
In the end, Ristolainen stayed in Philadelphia, while Murphy was acquired by the Edmonton Oilers at 50% salary in exchange for a second-round pick.
A second-round pick that Hughes might wish he had spent now that Carrier is sidelined for another few weeks.
In Brief
– Don't miss it.
Game day! It's game day!
Place Bell
3:00 p.m.
Sick Media
RDS
AHLTV on @FloHockey
https://t.co/uBnOmp91La#GoRocket
@EssorAssurances
pic.twitter.com/5bjPAWEkVB— x – Laval Rocket (@RocketLaval) April 4, 2026
– Stay tuned.
Retool or rebuild? The Leafs are at a crossroads — but the belief inside the locker room hasn't wavered. @lukefoxjukebox explores the path forward in Toronto, goalie fights, coaching drama, and Ovi vs. Crosby in Quick Shifts. https://t.co/RIYGqPc9Bt
— Sportsnet (@Sportsnet) April 4, 2026
– For those interested.
GAME DAY
GAMEDAY
New England Revolution
@GilletteStadium
4:30 PM
CJAD 800
Apple TV
GO MONTREAL
#CFMTL @ChevroletCanada pic.twitter.com/CWBeoFwLOQ
— CF Montréal (@cfmontreal) April 4, 2026
– Wow, well done!
Getting back on the bike after that crash at the 2026 Olympics…
Tough doesn't even begin to describe her. pic.twitter.com/0wEB75wWIv
— JJ (@JINVISIBLEWOMAN) April 3, 2026
– The two men continue to battle for the top spot in men's tennis.
Alcaraz's throne under threat from Sinnerhttps://t.co/WkhegPXGna
— RDS (@RDSca) April 4, 2026
Place Bell
3:00 p.m.
Sick Media
RDS
AHLTV on
GAMEDAY
New England Revolution
4:30 PM