At the 2023 draft, the Canadiens held the fifth overall pick. And it took the opportunity to select David Reinbacher.
And with Matvei Michkov still available, it wasn't a unanimous choice.
Almost three years later, Reinbacher still hasn't played in the show. Injuries have really slowed down his development, to the point where there's cause for concern.
Kent Hughes, however, doesn't seem to mind too much. He still likes what he sees in his young defenseman (he obviously wasn't going to say otherwise), but he did note something interesting about the kid during his appearance on Basu & Godin Notebook:
With all the noise surrounding his selection since we turned up our noses at [Matvei] Michkov, we need to make sure he's really NHL-ready when we call him back. – Kent Hughes
What we understand, then, is that the fans' (negative) reaction to Reinbacher's choice is a game-changer in town. The club can't treat him as just another prospect: it has to make sure it doesn't make him look bad by bringing him to the NHL too quickly.
The GM knows that recalling a guy too quickly in a rebuild is a big risk to take. So he doesn't want to put Reinbacher, who's already under a lot of pressure (despite himself), in that situation.
It's interesting to wonder whether Reinbacher, in a world where he had another name, would ever have had a chance in Montreal. Perhaps not, given that injuries have slowed him down (and Hughes has admitted as much), but the question remains interesting.
The GM, for his part, is hoping that Reinbacher will be able to find consistency and play a full season as soon as possible. He also noted that Reinbacher is bigger now than he was when he was drafted.
We'll see how the club handles the next steps in terms of Reinbacher and his development, but almost three years after his selection, the reaction that followed still influences the Habs' decisions.
And that's just from the GM.
Overtime
– Speaking of Habs prospects.
Habs prospect Aatos Koivu scored a goal today for TPS Turku
– /r/Habs (@HabsOnReddit) January 23, 2026
– Not crazy.
Burrows, a role model for Bolduc? https://t.co/1lzsyNwzco
– TVA Sports (@TVASports) January 23, 2026
– What do you think?
Do you want to see Arber Xhekaj in the Habs lineup vs the Bruins tomorrow?
pic.twitter.com/hSXx2V65TN
– /r/Habs (@HabsOnReddit) January 23, 2026
– It's still the talk of the town.
Tony Marinaro and Jean-Charles Lajoie round up the hot topics surrounding the Habs
https://t.co/JWKa4P9ebC
– TVA Sports (@TVASports) January 23, 2026
– Interesting.
Stammer shouts out Marty St. Louis for having the most assists on his power play goals
pic.twitter.com/9lCxsGAkp9
– Sports on Prime Canada (@SportsOnPrimeCA) January 23, 2026
https://t.co/JWKa4P9ebC