The Maple Leafs are not having a great season. The club, which lost Mitch Marner last summer, has tried to make up for its loss… but the results aren't incredible so far.
The 18-15-6 record isn't terrible… but seeing them in sixth place in the Atlantic is a far cry from their standards in recent years.
And to explain that, we can turn to Auston Matthews. The latter has just 15 goals and 27 points in 33 games, which is a good step back from what he's done in the past.
The loss of Marner and injuries are factors that may explain this… but according to Jason Gregor, who discussed it on Sports 1440, there may be another element at play:
I hear Auston Matthews isn't having much fun in Toronto. – Jason Gregor
“I've heard rumblings that he's not loving life in Toronto.” @JasonGregor on Auston Matthews and the #LeafsForever.
Brought to you by Go Auto. pic.twitter.com/Omh7WecJem
– Sports 1440 (@Sports1440) December 30, 2025
Gregor then implied that if a player is unhappy somewhere, you have to wonder if his time is numbered with that team. And that, we agree, would be big news.
Matthews is in the second year of a four-year contract that pays him $13.25 million a year. But if Gregor's story is true, maybe he'll leave Toronto before then.
And after losing Marner, trading Matthews could signal the start of a rebuilding process in Toronto.
We're still a long way from such an outcome, of course, but we sense that what's been happening with Matthews over the past few months is peculiar. He's not performing up to his potential… and you have to wonder if that's because he's unhappy in Toronto.
But with his more difficult performances of late, you have to wonder if the Leafs would be in a position to trade him at full value. But that's another hypothetical scenario.
Overtime
– Why not?
Here's Michael Hage walking on the ice in shoes instead of skates. pic.twitter.com/yhStfJrzDb
– Steven Ellis (@SEllisHockey) December 31, 2025
– Interesting.
Elliotte Friedman: I did get a call from someone…saying they don't even think Pete DeBoer would take a job before the Olympics, that's his primary focus; I don't know what the likelihood of that is but I thought that call was pretty interesting – 32 Thoughts (12/29)
– NHL Rumor Report (@NHLRumorReport) December 31, 2025
– Nice win for Switzerland.
World Junior Championship | Switzerland beat Slovakia 3-2 to finish third in Group A https://t.co/58772LRGSv
– La Presse Sports (@LaPresse_Sports) December 31, 2025
– Lions win in Trois-Rivières.
VICTORY
Join us this Friday and Saturday as your Lions take on the Ghost Pirates again at Colisée Vidéotron!
The final score is brought to you by Trois-Rivières Chevrolet Buick GMC Cadillac Corvette.#5years of Roars pic.twitter.com/Rgyr4R6g35
– Trois-Rivières Lions (@Lions3r) December 31, 2025
