That’s the million-dollar question that Kent Hughes and Jeff Gorton will need to answer in the coming months. This season, Evans has reached another level, scoring 10 goals and 23 points in 37 games while becoming an essential piece in the team’s success, particularly on the penalty kill.
The question is whether Evans has really become that player or if he’s playing above his capabilities at the moment. On this, your opinion is as good as mine.
In short, while everyone has their opinion on the million-dollar question, Brian Wilde took the opportunity during his appearance on Tony Marinaro’s Sick Podcast to discuss the topic a bit… and he made a very interesting point: we greatly underestimate the impact of Kirby Dach’s late-season performance on the decision.
Because in fact, Dach’s performance going forward this season changes a lot.
Could Jake Evans be playing TOO well?! @BWildeMTL: “The popular sentiment right now is to sign him but the way he’s playing, he and his agent are smart enough to know somebody’s going to feel they need to make a splash on July 1st” #GoHabsGo #thesickpodcast | @TonyMarinaro pic.twitter.com/as1OMuuvMw
— The Sick Podcast with Tony Marinaro (@thesickpodcasts) January 3, 2025
That said, if Dach continues to struggle until the end of the year, the team will need to invest resources to fill the second center role. In that scenario, Dach would move to the third center position… and with Beck pushing, signing Evans at a high price wouldn’t make sense.
I’m among those who don’t really see the point of trading Evans at the deadline, even at a high price. Unless the team completely falls apart before the deadline and Evans’ salary demands are outrageous (like $5 million per year, for instance), the team is no longer at the stage where it needs to sell all its players for draft picks.
There are already so many prospects within the organization and the team still has a ton of picks in the coming years. Drafting another Filip Mesar or another Alex Newhook (via trade) isn’t as important as keeping the guys who provide good hockey.
Newhook or Evans?
Mesar or Evans?— Maxime Truman (@MaximeTruman) December 30, 2024
In a world where Dach plays great hockey until the end of the year and shows that he is still the potential future second center of the team, I would have no problem seeing the team give Evans a big contract. He is a true asset on the penalty kill, he’s well-liked in the locker room, and he is currently showing offensive potential.
I’m not saying he’s the new Artturi Lehkonen… but does the team really want to take that risk for another Justin Barron?
In brief
– Speaking of the wolf.
Like the Canadiens, Jake Evans’ stock is rising. He has been the team’s leading scorer for the past seven games
DETAILS: https://t.co/Myj2VUYaZP pic.twitter.com/NnDGu5dUBz
— NHL (@NHL_FR) January 3, 2025
– Ivan Demidov has a good preparation, says his coach.
– SKA coach Roman Rotenberg today on Ivan Demidov:
“You know, Ivan is a very hardworking guy & somewhere it needs to be limited. We had one player, I won’t mention his last name, he lived in the gym…Overtraining is also a bad story. I think Ivan didn’t go to the gym just… pic.twitter.com/gWILPmpEMF
— /r/Habs (@HabsOnReddit) January 3, 2025
– Interesting.
Three NHL GMs will attend the Rocket’s game against Abbotsford tonight: Kyle Dubas, Bill Armstrong, and Don Sweeney.
That’s very unusual. I don’t remember seeing so many important executives present at the same time for a game at Place Bell.
— Anthony Marcotte (@anthonymarcotte) January 3, 2025
– Nice pickup for the Dodgers.
The Dodgers’ Asian pipeline continues to fill up… and Roki Sasaki is still on the market. https://t.co/0XCvwlg6Cu
— Passion MLB (@passion_mlb) January 3, 2025